top of page

Permission to Speak

 

Since completing our first Kontrapunkt exhibition just over a year ago, the biggest revelation to us was how, despite not all being close as people beforehand, we had started experiencing the benefit (and the efficiency!) of shared trust and non-hierarchical decision- making processes - what we soon came to call the Kontrapunkt Method. As we reflected on its possibilities as a model for better living in the world, we knew we had to keep going because there was so much more that we could experiment with and learn. And not just among ourselves. The audience is, in fact, just as important in the Kontrapunkt Method, not simply as viewers but active participants in our collective gesture of art-making. The premise for this new Kontrapunkt project is simple enough: four voices, four very personal inspirations, four responses from each voice. The implications are however more complex. The permission mentioned in our title is, very importantly, taken as well as granted. It is taken by each of us in our individual choice of inspiration and also in our interpretation not only of that but of all the others' choices. It is granted in our trust in the others to find their own connections with each of our choices.

 

Observing and reflecting on the development of this give-and-take equilibrium has been the core of this project.

The etymology of the word permission contains two very important concepts for Kontrapunkt - those of "forward" and of "exchange". What is exchanged and what is moving forward is not just our voice, but our very understanding of ourselves, as well as of others. Our understanding of our own choices and of our own responses, our own life rhythms, our own working habits, our own processes.

 

Developing such an intimate relation with others means developing a more intimate relation with ourselves. If we started by thinking of "art as a verb", we are now also reflecting on "sharing as a method". The sharing does not stop at our close circle but has to extend completely to the audience. It is together with the audience that our collectivity is fully actualized.

 

With them, we all move forward once again, as we strive to understand each other through another level, another layer, of sharing where they too have to take and grant their own permission to speak. In this sense, the pieces that are made through this process are not important as a final product but as a challenge to understand that what is "mine" is in fact "ours" and then becomes "everybody's".

 

It is the dialogue and not the pieces that is the "precious product" here. We take our own permission to talk and we grant it to others and, as in polyphonic singing, individual melodies are not dispersed or diluted into the voice of the choir and instead become more powerful and self-aware as the sharing moves forward. But their potential is at its fullest when they operate in their context and belong, united, to their collectivity.  

Exhibition Statement by Lieta Marziali

IMG_4829.jpeg
IMG_4834.jpeg

All Those Choices, brooch, copper, ready-made aluminium, thread, steel. 75 mm x 8mm.

The title 'All Those Choices' is a fragment of the Wooden Toy song, which was the inspiration Luca brought to this project, and we all responded to it with objects/jewellery pieces and indeed, I had all those choices to make this piece.

 

Cornelia Parker’s installation called Perpetual Canon, which consists of sixty flattened instruments that once belonged to a brass band, is an artwork I am strongly connected with. It has a visual aesthetic that I resonate with and a concept I appreciate. 

 

The other element in this work is the song, Wooden Toy. I found the music a little disturbing, but not in a negative way. I must find the right word. In Hungarian, we say 'felkavaró,' which is something that can be both negative and positive simultaneously, and this is exactly what the music is to me. The web of threads I created plays with the idea of positive and negative simultaneously, as it is a safety net, but it also captures freedom—a little bit like home. So, I tried to reflect on the paradox I felt with the music of harmony and disharmony all at once.

IMG_4901.jpeg
IMG_4867.jpeg

On the Way, ring, Tyvek, copper, cotton cord, 65mm x 25 mm x 8mm.

This ring, On The Way, responds to a book titled 'The Living Mountain' by Nan Shepherd. In the book Lieta brought to our group exhibition - Permission to Speak-  as one of the four inspirations, I discovered a fragment that deeply resonated with my day-to-day reflections: "One cannot truly know the rivers until one has seen them at their sources; however, this journey to the sources is not to be undertaken lightly. One walks among elementals, and elementals are not governable."

 

In many ways, the book strongly connects with Rita's choice of inspiration,  a poem by Sandor Weores. In both texts, confronting what is hard to see and venturing into a challenging landscape reflects a level of self-awareness where we become prepared to face what was once hidden from us.

 

I felt these sentences could create a connection or conversation between people when shared. That's why I made these thin paper strips featuring the printed quote. They not only hold the ring together but can also be untied and gifted to someone. The ring's body is crafted from cord, symbolising the book's mountain climbing theme and allowing me to incorporate my fondness for coloured threads into this project.

 

Another essential element of the ring is that once you've given away all the paper strips, nothing will keep it together any longer. Alternatively, we can view it as an object for collecting sentences that resonate with us or offer teachings we are ready and able to comprehend. It serves as a vessel for preserving the wisdom and inspiration we encounter along our journey. When the time is right, we can share these collected sentiments with others, ultimately spreding these meaningful fragments into the world just as we receive them.

IMG_4883.jpeg

I Stand Still: object in 9 pieces, copper 62mm x 70mm, 2022-2023

"Don't give up on anything: because whoever gave up on something, he withered away. But don't be a slave to your wishes. 

Wandering with repressed passions is just as bitter as crumbling among unleashed passions.

If you indulge your desires: they will proliferate, and they will multiply. If you kill your desires, they come back as ghosts. If you tame your desires: you can yoke them and plow and sow with dragons like perfect power itself."

Sándor Weöres:Towards Fullness; ‘Taming Desires’


 

The text Rita brought as inspiration for our project/exhibition, titled "Permission to Speak," speaks about the balance in life that we need to discover. In response to the Weores text, I decided to revisit a bowl that I had initially worked on during my graduation year in 2023. It was an ambitious project, but I eventually abandoned it and chose a different direction.

 

The bowl had been sitting on my workbench, and now the moment was right to resume working on it. I chose to slice the bowl into nine pieces. What you can see, either in the exhibition or the photographs, are these nine pieces delicately balanced on one another, recreating the original form of a bowl. However, it is no longer a functional bowl; it falls apart at the slightest touch. It serves as a reminder of something that once functioned, and now it can only remain empty. It appears as one, yet it is nine.

 

The act of destroying and then creating something new, transforming it into something else, and changing its original function is an intense form of expression that I enjoy using. For me, the process of unlearning what I have been taught and finding my freedom in the act of creation is complex, and here, I have taken the first steps toward this goal.

IMG_4847.jpeg
IMG_4841.jpeg

Can You Really Tell A Dream Without Ruining It? ring, paper, acrylic paint, copper, 115mm x 85mm x 10mm, 2022-2023

My creative process is almost always based on the extensive and thorough time I spend with my sketchbook. It has become a fundamental element of my creative process, and people consistently react to my collages, mark-making, and paintings. I have been encouraged for some years now to find a way to transform these 2D works into 3D jewellery pieces, and I have tended to do so. Now, with this project, I have, in a way, provided an answer to that encouragement in the form of a ring. It features a painting on one side and a paper cutout on the other, securely fixed together with an oxidized copper ring that pierces the paper, creating a hole for wearability. Although not the most convenient or comfortable ring to wear, it has an aesthetic representation that I am pleased with and perhaps from other old paintings and collages of mine I will create a collection of these wearable sketches.

Screenshot 2025-08-28 at 18.01.12.png

Kontrapunkt No. 2: Exploring the Artistic Process

A conversation between the artists - read the interview here.

bottom of page